I. Management
Definition: Coordination of resources within an organization to achieve goals through proper resource utilization. A part of an organization ensuring coordination between resources and driving them towards organizational objectives.
Views on Management:
- American View: Management is a part of administration (broader approach). Supporter: Robinsohn.
- Anglo View: Management is broader than administration; administration is a part of management. Supporters: British scholars.
- Third View: Administration and management are synonyms. Supporters: Fayol, Mooney, Gulick, Urwick (classical thinkers).
Difference between Administration and Management (Oliver Sheldon, Philosophy of Management, 1923):
Feature Administration Management Definition Collective effort towards a goal. Part of organization coordinating resource utilization. Scope Broader Narrower Focus Leadership, coordination Resource utilization Goal Setting Determines goals and objectives Implements effective work performance to achieve goals
II. Corporate Governance
Origins: Emerged post-1991 LPG (Liberalization, Privatization, Globalization) reforms in India to address increased private sector activity and associated scandals (e.g., KingFisher Airlines, Nirav Modi). Needed to protect stakeholder and shareholder rights.
Definition: Sum of ideas, goals, values, and principles inspiring the private/corporate sector towards transparency, accountability, responsibility, and impartiality.
Basic Objective: Protect the rights of shareholders and stakeholders.
Key Contributors:
- Adolph A. Berle Jr. and Gardiner C. Means (The Modern Corporation and Private Property) – early explanation of the concept.
- Cadbury Committee (UK) – popularized the concept.
Regulatory Structure:
- Shareholders: Numerous individuals owning company shares.
- Board of Directors: Makes decisions on behalf of shareholders.
- CEO: Heads company management and employees.
- Management: Implements decisions.
Stakeholders: Employees, suppliers, creditors, community, consumers.
Features: Emphasizes transparency, accountability, responsibility, and impartiality in the private/corporate sector. Corporate entities should be a medium for public welfare. Supports development of codes of conduct and ethical values in the private sector. A multi-dimensional approach.
Reasons for Origin: Impact of 1991 LPG reforms; need to protect shareholder and stakeholder rights; reduce scams and scandals; inspiration from bureaucratic reforms; impact of information technology.
Impact/Importance: Ensures transparency, accountability, responsibility, and impartiality; reduces scams and scandals; increases reliability of the corporate sector; increases investment and profit; increases flow of international capital; enables environmental protection; enables private organizations to become mediums for public welfare; develops ethical values in the private sector.
Government of India Efforts:
- Committees: N.R. Narayana Murthy Committee (2003), Kumar Mangalam Birla Committee (1999), Uday Kotak Committee (2017), Narendra Kumar Committee (2002), M.N. Goiporia Committee (1997), and others.
- Companies Act, 2013 (Section 135 – CSR provision).
- SEBI (Securities and Exchange Board of India, 1988 – statutory status in 1992): Protects shareholder and investor rights.
- ICAI (Institute of Chartered Accountants of India): Sets accounting standards.
- ICSI (Institute of Company Secretaries of India): Sets standards for general meetings of corporate and private sectors.
- NFCG (National Foundation for Corporate Governance): Government-sponsored organization to create awareness.
Principles of Corporate Governance:
- Rights of Shareholders: Participation in decision-making, profit sharing, and access to company information.
- Equitable Treatment of Shareholders: Equal treatment in profit distribution.
- Rights of Stakeholders: Role in decision-making and legal rights protection.
- Responsibility of the Board of Directors: Accountability to shareholders.
- Disclosure and Transparency: Transparent appointment of board members, selection of audit firms, employee salaries, committee formation, and profit reporting.
- Integrity: Ethical values and integrity within corporate organizations; development of a code of conduct.
III. Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR)
Legal Basis: Section 135 of the Companies Act, 2013.
Definition: Activities undertaken by the private sector beyond profit generation, considering social and environmental impacts.
Legal Binding: Companies with a turnover of ₹1000 crore, net worth of ₹500 crore, or average net profit of ₹5 crore over the preceding three years are legally required to spend 2% of their profits on CSR activities.
CSR Committee: Advises company management on CSR activities.
CSR Activities (as per Companies Act): Education, health, drinking water, environmental conservation, promotion of sports, sanitation, and promotion of renewable energy.
Types of CSR: Environment-based (conservation, renewable energy, eco-friendly techniques), human resource-based (employee benefits, human rights protection, safety measures), community-based (education, health, sanitation, drinking water), philanthropic-based (donations, grants).
Benefits of CSR (Social Level & Company Level):
- Medium for public welfare and socio-economic change.
- Reduces government workload.
- Creates brand image and increases company credibility.
- Increases investment and indirectly increases company profit.
- Motivates employees.
- Develops cordial relations between employees and management.
- Improves political relations.
- Ensures qualitative goods for consumers.
- Aids in the implementation of corporate governance.
Arguments Against Mandatory CSR: It's an ethical and moral duty, not a compulsory requirement; it's a new form of tax; it increases government interference in the private sector; companies need shareholder permission for expenditures.
Limitations of CSR: Expenditure disproportionately focused on health and education; geographical disparities; lack of awareness; lack of strict provisions; lack of cooperation between local administration and companies.
Suggestions for Improvement: Include CSR in school and college curricula; stricter penalties for non-compliance; mandatory CSR expenditure in rural areas; raise awareness; reduce geographical disparities; improve cooperation between local administration and companies.